ECJ Case Forces HMRC to (Grudgingly) Accept Taxpayers’ Use of ‘Lennartz’ |
 |
 |
|
VAT Voice by Andrew Needham Andrew Needham, Director of VAT Solutions (UK) Ltd, outlines a recent case supporting the Lennartz principle for the recovery of VAT on mixed use assetsBackgroundThe 1991 ‘Lennartz’ ECJ decision established a principle for the recovery of VAT on assets with both business and private use. The principle established in Lennartz (and later in ‘Bakcsi’), was that a taxable person may take initial input tax deduction on the full cost of goods purchased as a business asset and then recognise a corresponding obligation to account for output tax on the private use of the goods.In 2003, the ECJ reconfirmed this principle in a case concerned with the construction costs of a building used partly as a private residence. The decision conflicted with legislation that HMRC had just proposed preventing the use of the Lennartz principle for buildings and civil engineering works. HMRC considered the case concerned, but stated that there was a derogation in Article 6(2) of the EU 6th Directive that allows Member States to withdraw the Lennartz mechanism altogether for certain assets, so there is no output tax on deemed supplies relating to private use, and no right to full deduction of VAT incurred on those assets. However, they did make some minor amendments to their legislation, stating “the Lennartz mechanism is not available for land, buildings or civil engineering works (or services related to them such as construction services) where no entitlement for any qualifying input tax arose prior to 9 April 2003”. ECJ DecisionIn a recent ECJ decision (P Charles, TS Charles-Tijmens (C-434/04)) the court again found in favour of the taxpayer. This case involved the purchase of a holiday bungalow for both business and private use. The ECJ reaffirmed the validity of the Lennartz mechanism, and stated that it can be used for the deduction of VAT on land, buildings, construction, and civil engineering works, where it is shown as a business asset.Grudgingly, HMRC has had to agree that its previous legislation was not in line with the EC 6th Directive, and that the Lennartz mechanism can be used for the deduction of input VAT in the above circumstances (see Business Brief 15/05). Businesses do not have to use this method for VAT deduction on business assets, but can deduct a percentage of the VAT at the time of purchase in line with its proposed business/private use. Businesses that had wished to use the Lennartz mechanism for the purchase of eligible assets, but were prevented from doing so by HMRC, will now be able to make a backdated claim on purchases made after 9 April 2003, provided the claim is made within six months. HMRC point out that where Lennartz is used for the deduction of VAT on goods, including land and property, the goods are treated as wholly business assets. Therefore, when the asset is sold or the business deregisters for VAT, VAT is due on the full selling price (or deemed value on deregistration). However, where only a percentage of the purchase VAT was deducted at the time of purchase, only that same percentage of output tax need be accounted for when the asset is sold (or on deregistration). September 2005 Andrew Needham Director, VAT Solutions (UK) Ltd Email: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it VAT Solutions (UK) Ltd 11 Winmarleigh Street, Warrington, WA1 1NB (T) 01925 242497 (F) 01925 242498 (M) 07810 433927 (W) www.vatsolutions-uk.com VAT Solutions (UK) Limited is an established independent firm of Chartered Tax Advisers, formed by Andrew Needham and Steve Allen. The company has a cross-section of clients from multi-national companies through to medium-sized and numerous smaller regional firms of accountants and solicitors. They produce a regular publication 'VAT Voice', which can be downloaded directly from the Internet via the following address: www.vatsolutions-uk.com/newsletter.doc |
|
About The Author  Mark McLaughlin is TaxationWeb's Co-Founder, Director and Technical Editor. He is a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Taxation and a member of the Association of Taxation Technicians and the Society of Trust and Estate Practitioners. He lectures on tax subjects, is co-author of Tottel's IHT Annual and Ray & McLaughlin's IHT Planning, and Editor of Tottel's Tax Planning and Annual series. Mark's work has also been published in Taxation, Tax Adviser, Tolley's Practical Tax, Tax Journal and Simon's Weekly Tax Intelligence. Since January 1998, Mark has been a consultant in his own tax practice, Mark McLaughlin Associates, which provides tax consultancy and support services to professional firms. He publishes a regular 'Tax Update' e-Newsletter for clients and other professional firms. To receive future copies, contact Mark via his website. |
|
Article Added Saturday, 08 October 2005 |
Tax Insider Lite
Each month our tax experts reveal FREE tax strategies to help minimise your taxes. Get Tax Insider Lite:
Tax Books
BOOK OF THE WEEK
Inheritance Tax Simplified 2010/2011
Inheritance Tax Simplified provides the simple facts on inheritance tax and estate planning, and gives plenty of examples on how to plan to mitigate and reduce or provide for inheritance taxes, whilst successfullly planning your estate, wills and trusts.
BOOK OF THE MONTH
Bloomsbury's Tax Rates and Tables 2010/11
This new 250 page book from Bloomsbury Professional will provide you with comprehensive, post-Finance Act and post-Finance (No.2) Act coverage of the new revised tax rates,allowances and reliefs for JUST £12! Why pay more?
Capital Gains Tax 2010/11
"impressive mix of simplicity and detail, which could be used alongside the legislation for comprehensive coverage" TaxWriter, Mar 2007
Covering all the capital gains reliefs and exemptions that apply to individuals and trustees.
The Red Books 2010-11
Contains the complete set of direct taxes contained within five volumes and includes a separate index volume.
Core Tax Annuals 2010/11 Full Set plus CD-ROM
Great value in-depth tax guides that cover all facets of UK taxation - why go elsewhere? This set of Core Tax Annuals from Bloomsbury Professional's leading UK tax authors are available at the incredible price of JUST £150!
PROUDLY SUPPORTING
