This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more about cookies on this website and how to delete cookies, see our Cookie Policy.
Analytics

Tools which collect anonymous data to enable us to see how visitors use our site and how it performs. We use this to improve our products, services and user experience.

Essential

Tools that enable essential services and functionality, including identity verification, service continuity and site security.

Where Taxpayers and Advisers Meet
Dundas and the Curious Case of the Late Capital Allowances Claim
20/08/2019, by BKL, Tax Articles - Business Tax
773 views
1
Rate:
Rating: 1/5 from 1 people

BKL looks at the recent Dundas case on Capital Allowances that were claimed out of time - until HMRC opened tax enquiries.

When is a time limit not a time limit? On the evidence of the Tribunal case of Revenue and Customs v Dundas Heritable Ltd (Tax) [2019] UKUT 208 (TCC) (2 July 2019), it’s when the time limit relates to a company’s claim to capital allowances.

The rules that apply to claims to capital allowances are different from those that govern other claims. Except in a few special cases which we’ll ignore for the purposes of this note, capital allowances must be claimed as part of a tax return – there can be no “free-standing” claims as there can with some other reliefs.

For Income Tax purposes, there is no express statutory guidance as to the time limits for making or amending a claim: but HMRC draw the conclusion – to us, a slightly questionable one – that if any claim must be made as part of the tax return, it inevitably follows that “the time limit for making a claim or amending a claim is the normal time limit for making or amending a tax return”.

The time limits for filing and amending a tax return for a tax year are, respectively, 31 January after the end of the tax year and the following 31 January. So you might conclude that for Income Tax purposes, capital allowances for the year 2017/18, for example, must normally be claimed in a tax return made by 31 January 2019 but that, once made, the claim can be amended at any time up to 31 January 2020. In fact, HMRC seem to take the view – presumably to be consistent with the Corporation Tax position described below – that the initial claim can be made at any time up to 31 January 2020. But, in HMRC’s view, if you file your 2017/18 tax return later than 31 January 2020, you cannot claim capital allowances for the year.

For Corporation Tax purposes the law is more specific. It provides (at FA 1998 Sch18 para 82) that “a claim for capital allowances may be made, amended or withdrawn at any time up to whichever is the last of the following dates” and lists four dates of which the first two are “the first anniversary of the filing date for the company tax return” (so normally two years after the end of the accounting period) and “if notice of enquiry is given into that return, 30 days after the enquiry is completed”.

Dundas Heritable Ltd filed its tax return for the year to 31 March 2012 on 3 February 2015, and the return for the year to 31 March 2013 on 26 November 2015. Both were therefore filed late (that is, later than the statutory “filing date” for the accounting period) and both contained claims to capital allowances that were (other than their timing) uncontroversial.

For each year, HMRC opened an enquiry into the tax return in respect of the capital allowance claim and subsequently issued a closure notice denying relief on the grounds that the claim was out of time.

The company argued that the plain wording of paragraph 82 provided that, in a case where an enquiry was made, a claim to capital allowances was within time if made at a time that was earlier than “30 days after the enquiry is completed”. That was so in this case, so the claims were in time and should be allowed.

Before the First-tier Tribunal, HMRC asserted that the key point was that the validity of a claim had to be determined at the time it was made and by reference to the time limits applicable at that time: nothing that subsequently happened could operate to “post-validate” a claim that was invalid when made. They also observed that “in order to remove a late claim HMRC must open an enquiry”.

Having lost at the First-tier Tribunal, they developed that point further at the Upper Tribunal: “An analysis which permitted an out of time claim to be validated by the very process required for corrective action was entirely circular and rendered the initial time limit in subparagraph (a) otiose.” Very fair point, well made, we’d have said.

Both the First-tier and now the Upper Tribunal sided with the company, reasoning that the legislation is unequivocal in listing four dates and in providing that a claim would be timeous if made “at any time” before the last of them. The company’s claim had been made before the last date had passed: it was therefore in time.

The decision is surprising. The effect seems to be to allow a company to make a claim for capital allowances in any tax return, regardless of how late the tax return is made. For in such a case the claim can be challenged only by the making of an enquiry into the return; and the very fact of the making (or, at least, completing) of the enquiry retrospectively extends the time limit for making the claim: a sort of Catch-22 against HMRC.

This can hardly have been the result that Parliament envisaged when enacting the provision. But unless and until the law is changed or the case is reversed on appeal, that is how things stand: a decision of the Upper Tribunal (unlike the First-tier Tribunal) has the force of precedent.

About The Author

BKL is a business name of Berg Kaprow Lewis LLP, Chartered Accountants and Tax Advisers, a limited liability partnership registered in England and Wales.

The information in this article is intended for guidance only. It is based upon our understanding of current legislation and is correct at the time of publication. No liability is accepted by Berg Kaprow Lewis LLP for actions taken in reliance upon the information given and it is recommended that appropriate professional advice should be taken.

BKL
35 Ballards Lane
London
N3 1XW
(T) 020 8922 9222 
(W) www.bkl.co.uk

Back to Tax Articles
Comments

Please register or log in to add comments.

There are not comments added

Tony Talks - 

ICPA Chairman, Tony Margaritelli discusses Defining Moments that made him go WOW and he takes a look at GDPR which hasn't gone away in his latest in practice blog.