This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more about cookies on this website and how to delete cookies, see our Cookie Policy.
Analytics

Tools which collect anonymous data to enable us to see how visitors use our site and how it performs. We use this to improve our products, services and user experience.

Essential

Tools that enable essential services and functionality, including identity verification, service continuity and site security.

Where Taxpayers and Advisers Meet
Welcome News for "Mixed" UK VAT Groups: Advocate General's Opinion on Irish VAT Groups Says Non-Taxable Members are Eligible
28/11/2012, by Lee Sharpe, Tax News - VAT & Excise Duties
5401 views
0
Rate:
Rating: 0/5 from 0 people

Introduction

The Advocate General delivered his opinion yesterday (27 November) on whether or not non-taxable persons could validly be included in a VAT group. The Irish case has strong parallels with the domestic treatment here in the UK and will be encouraging for the many UK businesses with VAT groups containing passive holding companies, and/or dormant companies, pending formal judgment expected early 2013.

Background

Several countries, including the UK and Ireland, allow non-taxable persons to be included in VAT groups for ease of administration. From a UK perspective, a typical example would be a holding company that does little more than passively hold shares in the group's 'active' companies. Or, a dormant subsidiary that is maintained within an overarching group registration for convenience.

From a UK perspective, membership of a VAT group may potentially also allow a non-taxable but active company (e.g., a charity) to reclaim Input VAT under the Partial Exemption rules, thereby granting an opportunity to reclaim VAT that it might not enjoy as a standalone company.

Other member states have objected to this facility and almost exactly three years ago, the European Commission instigated infringement proceedings which required the 'offending' countries to change their domestic rules in line with other member states. If the UK had simply complied, it might have meant that large numbers of UK VAT groups would have had to eject their holding companies, and/or dormant members. However, HMRC has consistently disagreed with the European Commission on this point, and has since robustly defended the UK position alongside its fellow recalcitrants.

Opinion

The Advocate General has published his opinion on the Irish case as being broadly representative of the issues at stake for the other countries and his opinion resoundingly favours the argument that non-taxable persons may be included, for instance at paragraph 52:

"However, in my opinion it is not an anomaly that non‑taxable persons can belong to a VAT group."

Of course it is the judgment in the UK Case C86-11 which is most important but the judgment is rarely at odds with the Advocate General's opinion, which bodes well for the final decision next year.

About The Author

Lee is TaxationWeb's Articles & News Editor and writes for TaxationWeb. He is a Chartered Tax Adviser with experience of advising individuals and owner-managed businesses over a broad spectrum of tax matters.
Back to Tax News
Comments

Please register or log in to add comments.

There are not comments added

Tony Talks - 

ICPA Chairman, Tony Margaritelli discusses late rules on exemptions for MTD4Vat, why HMRC simply can't cope and what's coming up this month.