| Home > Tax Articles > General > TRAINING ON THE WRONG TRACK? |
| TRAINING ON THE WRONG TRACK? |
 |
 |
|
Brass Tax by BKL Tax BKL Tax point out anomalies in the tax deductibility of training costs.Dass v Special Commissioner and others [2006] All ER (D) 152 (Oct)The recent High Court case of Dass underlines the anomalies which exist in the area of training costs.BackgroundMr Dass was a self-employed tutor of English and, broadly, educational adviser. He undertook (as a student) a two-year course in law. He failed to get tax relief for the cost which was held to be capital in nature on first principles, on the grounds that "the course was not a 'refresher' course to brush up or 'hone' the taxpayer's expertise, but was directed at equipping him with a new qualification enabling him to enter into a new area of practice".A different result?The odd thing is that if Mr Dass had traded through a limited company, and if the company had paid for the course, it is very likely that the tax position would have been entirely different: there would have been no benefit in kind assessable on Mr Dass (by virtue of ITEPA s250) and it is very unlikely that HMRC would have sought to disallow the cost as capital expenditure in the hands of the company: as HMRC themselves say in the context of a company "we find it difficult to imagine circumstances likely to occur in practice where the benefit which the employer obtains can be viewed as an identifiable capital asset. Such factors as the pace of technological and commercial change and an employee's right to resign and seek work elsewhere militate against such a view." Why this analysis (at least in respect of the "pace of change") should be accepted for a company but not for a self-employed trader is a mystery to us. Unfortunately Mr Dass was advocate in his own cause before the Special Commissioner and in the High Court and the apparent inconsistency of the HMRC view does not seem to have been drawn to the attention of either.Even curiouser is the fact that although the tax system is relatively benign in respect of the training costs borne by the employer there are no special reliefs for identical costs borne by employees themselves: such costs must pass the notoriously strict test of being "wholly exclusively and necessarily incurred in the performance of the duties" and very few training costs borne by employees will qualify. So an employee wanting to improve himself will often be well-advised to negotiate a salary sacrifice with his employer in return for the employer's agreement to provide the training in question. CommentIt is surely only a matter of time before these anomalies are corrected. Meanwhile, advisers should be aware that in the field of tax relief for training costs, common sense and logic are no guide.Brass Tax October 2006 About BKL TaxBKL Tax is a division of Berg Kaprow Lewis LLP. For information about BKL Tax Consultancy Services, visit www.bkltax.co.uk or call 020 8922 9222 for telephone support.Brass Tax®Brass Tax is intended for general guidance only and no liability is accepted for actions taken in reliance upon these notes. Where appropriate professional advice should be taken. Such advice is available under the terms of the BrassTax®Plus service. See the BKL Tax website for details. www.bkltax.co.uk.
|
|||
|
About The Author  Mark McLaughlin is TaxationWeb's Co-Founder, Director and Technical Editor. He is a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Taxation and a member of the Association of Taxation Technicians and the Society of Trust and Estate Practitioners. He lectures on tax subjects, is co-author of Tottel's IHT Annual and Ray & McLaughlin's IHT Planning, and Editor of Tottel's Tax Planning and Annual series. Mark's work has also been published in Taxation, Tax Adviser, Tolley's Practical Tax, Tax Journal and Simon's Weekly Tax Intelligence. Since January 1998, Mark has been a consultant in his own tax practice, Mark McLaughlin Associates, which provides tax consultancy and support services to professional firms. He publishes a regular 'Tax Update' e-Newsletter for clients and other professional firms. To receive future copies, contact Mark via his website. |
|||
|
Article Added Saturday, 11 November 2006 | 2460 Hits |
|||
Tax Insider Lite
Each month our tax experts reveal FREE tax strategies to help minimise your taxes. Get Tax Insider Lite:
Tax Books
BOOK OF THE WEEK
Tax Planning 2012/13
BOOK OF THE MONTH
Dealing with HMRC Investigations 2012/13
PROUDLY SUPPORTING
