Are you a member ?
  • Editorial

    Guilty Even if Innocent..?

    HMRC has published a consultation on new laws which will enable it to prosecute even innocent taxpayers as criminals. Your only ‘crime’ would be to have received income, or to have made a capital gain, outside the UK, and not to have paid UK tax on it - even if you didn't know you had to.

    For those who would say that anyone who deliberately evades tax ‘deserves what they get’, then I would agree – where someone deliberately does so. But this proposed legislation will apply whether someone has done something deliberately or accidentally: under these new rules, innocence is irrelevant – that’s the point of a “strict liability” offence. Neither HMRC nor the courts are going to waste time trying to establish whether or not the accused tried deliberately to evade tax.

    For those who might say that it is about time that measures were introduced to combat the outrageous activities of some of the super-rich, which is causing ‘real harm’ to the UK economy, then I would agree with that as well – although I would also say that I thought we probably already had such laws. But this legislation will not attack global corporates or complex structures: it is aimed at individuals only. The consultation complains about how difficult it is to tackle offshore facilitators of such evasion, but these measures don’t do anything about that either. And although HMRC proposes to overlook smaller ‘misdemeanours’, that proposed limit is less than £2,000 – hardly pop star or oligarch territory. You have to wonder how many people need to omit £2,000 offshore tax, to damage the UK economy.

    HMRC might argue that £2,000 may be a relatively small amount of money but if that’s bank interest, then it represents a very substantial capital sum being hidden offshore. And I would agree with that too. But the proposed legislation does not ‘care’ about that capital sum or its origins, whether it be from historic undeclared takings ‘salted away’ offshore, or a legitimate inheritance. So a small capital gain of £5,000 on the sale of my Thai holiday home could end up with my being clapped in irons – even if I paid the relevant tax in Thailand, not realising that I might also be taxable thereon in UK.

    HMRC’s consultation talks about ‘safeguards’ – such as the aforementioned de minimis threshold which ignores small (arguably miniscule) amounts. HMRC intends to apply the legislation only to income or gains in ‘unapproved’ countries. So it seems that criminality may be determined in some cases by an accident of geography (let’s not forget, we are talking about innocent errors here, since we basically have no issue as regards those who deliberately underpay – although consistency would be appropriate).

    HMRC also says that it will apply its current Criminal Investigation Policy which means, in its own words, that "non-compliance will usually be pursued through civil means". 

    There are many things that this proposed legislation does not do. But what it will do, is allow HMRC to increase its criminal prosecution statistics with minimal cost and effort.  HMRC has set itself the task of a five-fold increase in criminal prosecutions, and has already linked these proposals to that target. One of the reasons why the bar is consistently set so high in most criminal cases is to prevent unfairness and miscarriages of justice. A civil service with a burning desire to criminalise citizens and without that high bar? It can end only one way.

    Regards all,

    TW Ed


TaxationWeb is a free database of UK tax information for accountants and the general public.

Feel free to find out more about us

Tax Tips Forum is a free service. Taxpayers can add questions or comments to the site on tax problems or tax matters in general. Accountants, tax advisers and others are invited to offer practical help and advice in a free and open forum.

Browse through our selection of tax articles written by tax specialist on a wide range of tax issues.

Do you have any interesting tax news, points of practice or press releases relating to taxation issues? Please contact us with this information, for inclusion in the news section of this site.

Advertise on TaxationWeb! - do you offer tax related products or services? Would your company benefit from being exposed to thousands of highly-targeted visitors a month? Contact us for details of advertising on TaxationWeb.

I was looking for some guidance on share buy-backs under Companies Act 2006 and you had the perfect article. It was just what I needed to point me in the right direction. Thank you, and I will tell all my contacts to visit your site. - Pascale Wood-Atkins, Wood-Atkins Commercial Law

I would like to say how impressed i am with your site which i have found very useful on several occassions. - Paul, via e-mail

Great site. Answered a car allowance question in under an hour ! - Rudy, via e-mail

I had the HMRC claiming an overpaymet of over £5000 and took them all the way through county court.. four hearings blah blah... anyway I won my case the HMRC never showed for the last hearing and the claim was struck out....  the information on your web site was important in this case..  and gave me the reassurance that i was right to continue my defense against such a ridiculous claim. - Sharron, via e-mail

Tax professionals and public alike all benefit from the varied help & advice. Haven't seen any other site like this. Brilliant! - Caron Smeaton, Thompson Kimti Ltd

Excellent innovative site. Well done! - Steven, via e-mail

Very well set-out & informative site. Good luck with it! - Colin Baines, Seymour Taylor

I found this website most interesting and impressive. - Denis Cremin, Ryan Glennon & Company

So far, an excellent site which does what it says. A great rarity on the net. Well done! - Mark, via e-mail

Get our free Newsletter

You are:
You are interested in (tick all that apply):


   "5 Top Tips            for Referral            Business"    For a new video blog from Tony Magaritelli

Click Here

Tax Books


VAT Registration Handbook

A new guide to VAT Registration, showing why the topic is more complex than it may seem.


Guide to Taxpayers' Rights and HMRC Powers, 3rd edition

This superb title from leading practitioner Robert Maas provides a thorough examination of statutory provisions on which HMRC's approach to investigations, to tax collection and to penalties, is based.
Stamp Duty Land Tax (3rd edition)

A direct and approachable guide to the complexities of SDLT.
Employee Benefits & Expenses: 2-volume bundle

Clear, practical commentary on the taxation of employee benefits and expenses, across two volumes, with a discounted price when both books bought together.
Booth and Schwarz: Residence, Domicile and UK Taxation, 17th edition

Booth & Schwarz: Residence, Domicile and UK Taxation, 17th edition provides a crisp analysis of this rapidly developing subject and expertly examines residence and other fiscal connections for individuals, companies and trusts.
Hitwise Award Winner Apr-Jun 2008 Hitwise Award Winner Jul-Sep 2008 Hitwise Award Winner Oct-Dec 2008 Hitwise Award Winner Jan-Jun 2009 Hitwise Award Winner Jul-Dec 2009 Hitwise Award Winner 2011 Alexa - Most popular news and media website

TaxationWeb Limited (Registered in England No. 4571386), 6 Coleby Avenue, Peel Hall, Manchester, M22 5HH, United Kingdom

By using this website, you agree to using cookies. Cookies are small text files stored on your browser when you use websites and applications (learn more about cookies).
You can control how websites use cookies by configuring the privacy settings within your browser (please refer to your browser help function to learn more about cookie controls).
Note that if you disable cookies entirely, there are parts of this website which may not function properly (e.g. logging in, commenting, etc).

Website by Dorifor Internet Marketing