This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more about cookies on this website and how to delete cookies, see our Cookie Policy.

Tools which collect anonymous data to enable us to see how visitors use our site and how it performs. We use this to improve our products, services and user experience.


Tools that enable essential services and functionality, including identity verification, service continuity and site security.

Where Taxpayers and Advisers Meet
Sale of Goodwill: Is it Income or Capital?
07/12/2020, by Mark McLaughlin CTA (Fellow) ATT TEP, Tax Articles - General
Rating: 1/5 from 1 people

Mark McLaughlin looks at a case on the tax treatment for a professional consultant who sold his business.


It is common in many occupations and professions (e.g. law, medicine) for individuals to be engaged as self-employed consultants. Some consultants will build up their own practices before eventually selling them.

From a tax perspective, the question arises as to how the practice disposal proceeds should be treated. For example, is it an income or capital receipt? If capital, could anti-avoidance provisions apply to treat the capital receipt as income (and therefore potentially taxable at higher rates)? These issues were considered in Villar v Revenue and Customs [2019] UKFTT 0117 (TC).

In that case, the taxpayer (a renowned orthopaedic surgeon) entered into an agreement with a company for the sale and purchase of the taxpayer’s business in March 2010. The taxpayer received £1 million upon completion. When submitting his self-assessment return for 2009/10, the taxpayer returned the £1 million payment as a capital receipt. Following an enquiry into the tax return, HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) assessed the £1 million payment as income. The taxpayer appealed.

HMRC argued:

  1. That the payment was in fact revenue in nature, being effectively an advance for services provided and so subject to income tax;
  2. Alternatively, that even if the receipt was capital in law, it should be treated as income under anti-avoidance provisions (in ITA 2007, Pt 13, Ch 4) concerning ‘sales of occupation income’.

Income or Capital?

The First-tier Tribunal noted that the taxpayer’s particular method of carrying on the business resulted in a book of customers which provided repeat business, and his name was capable of attracting customers, notwithstanding that not all medical services were provided by the taxpayer himself. By far the greater part of the value of the business was attributed to goodwill. The fact that much of the goodwill was connected with the taxpayer’s name, and the taxpayer continued to be known by that name, did not prevent him from having parted with the goodwill.

On HMRC’s argument (1), the tribunal concluded that the £1 million consideration received was a capital payment.

Sale of Occupation Income?

On HMRC’s argument (2) concerning the anti-avoidance rule, the first question was whether the arrangements the taxpayer entered into with the purchaser were ‘made to exploit the earning capacity of an individual in an occupation’, meaning the earning capacity of the taxpayer as an orthopaedic surgeon (ITA 2007 s 773(2)). The tribunal found it difficult to conclude that this pre-condition was met.

However, if it was met, the next question would be whether ‘one of the main objects of the…arrangements [was] the avoidance or reduction of liability to income tax’. The tribunal was not persuaded by HMRC's arguments on this point. The taxpayer's appeal was allowed.

Personal Goodwill

HMRC’s principal argument in Villar was that the taxpayer had no business to sell, on the basis that the goodwill was personal to him. HMRC’s guidance (in its Capital Gains manual at CG68010) indicates that any goodwill attributable to an individual’s personal skills is not capable of transfer to another person. Consultants who are selling their businesses should consider such possible challenges by HMRC.   

The above article was first published in Business Tax Insider (July 2019) (

About The Author

Mark McLaughlin is a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Taxation, a Fellow of the Association of Taxation Technicians, and a member of the Society of Trust and Estate Practitioners. From January 1998 until December 2018, Mark was a consultant in his own tax practice, Mark McLaughlin Associates, which provided tax consultancy and support services to professional firms throughout the UK.

Mark  is a consultant with The TACS Partnership LLP ( He is also editor and a co-author of HMRC Investigations Handbook (Bloomsbury Professional).

He is a member of the Chartered Institute of Taxation’s Capital Gains Tax & Investment Income and Succession Taxes Sub-Committees.

Mark is Chief Contributor to McLaughlin’s Tax Case Review, a monthly journal published by Tax Insider.

Mark is the Editor of the Core Tax Annuals (Bloomsbury Professional), and is a co-author of the ‘Inheritance Tax’ Annuals (Bloomsbury Professional).

Mark is Editor and a co-author of ‘Tax Planning’ (Bloomsbury Professional).

He is a co-author of ‘Ray & McLaughlin’s Practical IHT Planning’ (Bloomsbury Professional) 

Mark is a Consultant Editor with Bloomsbury Professional, and co-author of ‘Incorporating and Disincorporating a Business’. This content is available as part of a number of Bloomsbury Professional's online modules.

He is Editor and co-author of ‘HMRC Investigations Handbook‘ (Bloomsbury Professional).

Mark has also written numerous articles for professional publications, including ‘Taxation’, ‘Tax Adviser’, ‘Tolley’s Practical Tax Newsletter’ and ‘Tax Journal’, which provides free information and resources on UK taxes to taxpayers and professionals, and TaxationWeb’s sister site TaxBookShop.

Mark is a Director of Tax Insider, and Editor of Tax Insider, Property Tax Insider and Business Tax Insider, which are monthly publications aimed at providing tax tips and tax saving ideas for taxpayers and professional advisers. He is also Editor of Tax Insider Professional, a monthly publication for professional practitioners.

Mark is also a tax lecturer, and has featured in online tax lectures for Tolley Seminars Online.

Mark co-founded TaxationWeb ( in 2002.

Back to Tax Articles

Please register or log in to add comments.

There are not comments added

ICPA Chairman Tony Margaritelli discusses 3 topics centred around October, including: 1. HMRC Furlough Fraud & Fighting For Your Clients, 2. Think About Yourself, 3. Are You a HMRC Customer.