Forbes Dawson by Michael Dawson MA(Cantab) FCA ATIIIn today's uncertain world, how certain can an accountant or tax adviser be how the Inland Revenue will view a particular transaction? Michael Dawson of Forbes Dawson considers the extent to which clearance applications to the Inland Revenue provide comfort.Jeffrey Skilling, the former Enron Chief Executive, is reported to have blamed his ignorance on the Company’s financial troubles on the fact that he was not an accountant! In today’s uncertain world even the most qualified tax advisor cannot be certain how the Inland Revenue will view particular transactions. For this reason the ability to obtain statutory clearances is a vital safeguard for the client where large sums of money are involved.
The Inland Revenue are, in general, unwilling to express a formal view of transactions before they take place. Thankfully, they are obliged under the legislation to provide specific clearances for sales of shares. Further they have a strict time limit of 30 days to provide the clearance or to request further information.
A successful Inland Revenue clearance is, however, not a total panacea; the view expressed by the Revenue is limited to a statement that they will not apply a specific anti avoidance section. They also issue a standard disclaimer that leaves the ultimate decision on whether reliefs are available to the Local Inspector concerned.
The clearance can only be relied upon if all the relevant information about the transaction is provided. If, for instance, important information about the taxpayer’s future intentions is left out, the clearance could become null and void. A well set out clearance application can also serve to avoid detailed enquiries from the Inspector when the Self Assessment tax return is later submitted, often at a much later date.
Under Gordon Brown’s new regime of capital gains tax on business assets, the levels of CGT on the sale of shares are extremely favourable compared with the 40% income tax rate. Where shares have been held for more than two years, the effective rate of CGT can be as low as 10%. A Section 707 ICTA clearance provides comfort that lower capital gains rates of tax will apply.
For commercial reasons the purchaser often wants to pay part of the consideration on a deferred basis. This assists cash flow and may be linked to the warranties that the vendor has given. Where the purchaser is a listed company, it is also common for new shares to be issued as part of the deal.
Where ‘paper’ ie. loan notes or shares, is issued, capital gains can be rolled over until the future date of encashment or disposal. A specific clearance for this is available under Section 138 TCGA.
The Inland Revenue have challenged the availability of business asset taper relief on loan notes issued in exchange for shares. Fortunately they have now accepted that loan notes constitute business assets for taper relief purposes where other conditions are complied with. The loan notes must not be “Qualifying Corporate Bonds”, requiring a degree of complexity in the legal drafting.
If you require any further information on this subject, please do not hesitate to contact Michael Dawson on 0161 245 1090, or by e-mail at email@example.com.